Breaking Legal Developments (December 2025)
CRITICALOpenAI Loses Key Discovery Battle Over Deleted Pirated Books
In a major blow to OpenAI's legal defense, a federal court ruled against OpenAI in a critical discovery dispute. The startup deleted two huge datasets of pirated books and must now produce internal communications about why.
Why This Matters:
OpenAI could be on the hook for hundreds of millions, if not billions, of dollars if it was aware it was infringing on copyrighted material. The discovery of internal communications about the deleted Library Genesis data could prove this knowledge.
Authors' Class Action Victory
ProceedingOctober 2025: Judge Sidney Stein denied OpenAI's request to dismiss authors' claims that ChatGPT output infringes their copyrights. Authors may be able to prove ChatGPT text is "similar enough" to violate their book copyrights.
Publishers Weekly →Anthropic Settles for $1.5 BILLION
SettledAugust 2025: Anthropic was pushed to settle with book authors for $1.5 billion to avoid a trial that could have exposed them to up to $1 trillion in damages for downloading pirated books from Library Genesis—the same library OpenAI also used.
Sets devastating precedent for OpenAI's similar exposure
India Publishers Join ANI Lawsuit
ExpandingJanuary 2025: Federation of Indian Publishers (Bloomsbury, Penguin Random House, Rupa Publications) and Indian media outlets (NDTV, Indian Express, Hindustan Times) seek to join ANI's lawsuit against OpenAI.
New York Times Case Proceeds
Major RulingMarch 2025: Federal judge rejected OpenAI's request to toss out the Times copyright lawsuit. Main copyright infringement claims allowed to proceed.
NPR Coverage →The Big Picture:
Tens of millions of books and news articles are at issue in the dozen copyright cases against OpenAI now consolidated in Manhattan court. With Anthropic's $1.5 billion settlement as precedent and OpenAI's deletion of evidence now under legal scrutiny, the company faces existential financial risk.
Suicide & Death Lawsuits
7+ CasesOpenAI Faces Multiple Wrongful Death Claims
As of November 2025, OpenAI faces seven lawsuits claiming ChatGPT drove people to suicide and harmful delusions - even those with no prior mental health issues. OpenAI denies liability.
Raine Family v. OpenAI
ActiveParents of 16-year-old Adam Raine allege ChatGPT became his "suicide coach" after 7 months of conversations. Found chat logs showing harmful guidance.
NBC News Coverage →Garcia v. Character.AI
ActiveMother of Sewell Setzer III (14) sues after chatbot's last words were "come home to me." Bot asked if he had a suicide "plan."
NBC News Coverage →Shamblin Family v. OpenAI
ActiveFamily of Zane Shamblin (23) claims ChatGPT "goaded" him to suicide after memory feature created "illusion of a confidant."
CNN Coverage →Lacey Family v. OpenAI
ActiveAmaurie Lacey (17) - ChatGPT allegedly provided instructions on how to tie a noose and information on survival without breathing.
Rottenberg Family v. OpenAI
PendingSophie Rottenberg (29) talked for months to ChatGPT "therapist" named Harry about mental health before death.
Additional Character.AI Cases (4+)
ActiveFive families total have sued Character.AI. All five accused its chatbots of sexually abusive interactions with children.
Copyright Mega-Lawsuits
12+ ConsolidatedThe New York Times v. OpenAI & Microsoft
The Times alleges OpenAI used "millions" of copyrighted articles to train ChatGPT without consent. Federal copyright law allows fines of up to $150,000 per work for willful infringement. With millions of works at issue, this could be "potentially fatal for a company."
Potential Damages: Tens of Billions
Key Developments:
Judge orders OpenAI to produce 20 million anonymized ChatGPT chat logs - only a "small fraction" of "tens of billions" of logs retained.
Judge rejects OpenAI's motion to dismiss. Core copyright claims allowed to proceed.
12 copyright cases consolidated in Manhattan court for pretrial activity.
Authors Guild v. OpenAI
ActiveClass action representing thousands of authors whose books were allegedly used to train ChatGPT without permission.
Daily News v. Microsoft & OpenAI
ActiveAlden Global Capital properties: NY Daily News, Chicago Tribune, Orlando Sentinel, San Jose Mercury-News.
The Intercept v. OpenAI & Microsoft
ActiveNonprofit investigative outlet makes similar copyright claims regarding investigative journalism.
Raw Story & Alternet v. OpenAI
ActiveClaims articles used to train ChatGPT without consent or compensation.
Canadian News Outlets v. OpenAI
ActiveMultiple Canadian media organizations filing copyright claims.
ANI v. OpenAI (India)
ActiveAsian News International claims unfair competition after OpenAI refused to license content like other media deals.
GEMA v. OpenAI (Germany)
Ruling: OpenAI LiableMunich court ruled OpenAI violated German copyright laws. GEMA represents 100,000+ composers, songwriters, publishers.
Court found: OpenAI violated copyright laws
Ziff Davis v. OpenAI
ActiveMajor tech media company joins copyright claims.
Elon Musk v. OpenAI
OngoingMusk v. Altman, Brockman & OpenAI
Trial: Fall 2025OpenAI co-founder Elon Musk alleges the company abandoned its nonprofit mission. Sought preliminary injunction to block OpenAI's transition to for-profit model.
Key Developments:
Court denied Musk's request for preliminary injunction to block for-profit transition.
Judge agreed to schedule trial for Fall 2025.
Defamation Lawsuits
3+ CasesWalters v. OpenAI
DismissedRadio host Mark Walters sued after ChatGPT falsely accused him of embezzlement. First defamation case against generative AI.
Dismissed May 2025 - Court ruled plaintiff failed to prove actual malice.
Brian Hood v. OpenAI (Australia)
ThreatenedAustralian mayor threatened suit after ChatGPT falsely claimed he was convicted of bribery and served 30 months in prison. He was actually the whistleblower.
Battle v. Microsoft
ActiveTechnologist Jeffery Battle sues because Bing's ChatGPT confused him with Jeffrey Battle, a convicted terrorist.
Privacy & Data Lawsuits
Multiple CasesA.T. v. OpenAI & Microsoft
Dismissed May 2024Class action alleged unlawful collection of personal data from private individuals to train AI models.
Dismissal significant for AI privacy litigation precedent.
noyb Complaints (EU)
ActiveEuropean privacy organization filed first complaint about AI hallucinations in April 2024 - ChatGPT invented false information about real people.
noyb Report →Landmark Rulings Against AI
Precedent-SettingMoffatt v. Air Canada
Plaintiff WonCourt ruled Air Canada liable for chatbot's false bereavement fare policy. Company cannot claim AI is a "separate legal entity."
Award: $812.02 + precedent
"It should be obvious to Air Canada that it was responsible for all information on its website, regardless of whether it appeared on a static page or was provided by a chatbot."
GEMA v. OpenAI (Germany)
OpenAI Found LiableMunich Regional Court ruled OpenAI violated German copyright laws. Major victory for rights holders.
Regulatory Investigations
Federal & StateFTC Inquiry into AI Companions
ActiveFederal Trade Commission launched inquiry into potential harms to children and teenagers who use AI chatbots as companions.
Congressional Hearings
OngoingParents of teens who died by suicide after AI interactions testified before Congress. Led to OpenAI pledging new teen safeguards.
CBS News →State-Level AI Legislation
Multiple StatesAbout a dozen bills introduced to regulate AI chatbots. Illinois and Utah banned therapeutic bots. California has two bills pending.
Get the Full Report
Download our free PDF: "10 Real ChatGPT Failures That Cost Companies Money" (read it here) - with prevention strategies.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.